Welcome to Jerry's Pizza Mill
Jerry's Pizza Mill in Waialua, HI is a hidden gem known for its delicious pizza, homemade meatballs, and welcoming atmosphere. Customers rave about the Waialua Pepperoni and the Meatball pizza, all made with fresh ingredients and crispy crust. The BYOB policy adds a fun touch to the dining experience, and the friendly service keeps patrons coming back for more. Despite some minor setbacks mentioned in reviews, the overall consensus is that Jerry's Pizza Mill is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers on Oahu. So, if you find yourself craving a slice of authentic NYC-style pizza with a hint of CT-style flair, look no further than Jerry's Pizza Mill.
-
67-292 Goodale Ave Waialua, HI 96791 Hotline: (808) 637-8866
Welcome to Jerry's Pizza Mill, a hidden gem located at 67-292 Goodale Ave in Waialua, HI. This quaint restaurant offers a variety of delicious options ranging from mouth-watering pizzas to savory sandwiches.
Customers rave about the Waialua Pepperoni pizza, which is topped with sausage, mushroom, olive, tomato, and garlic for a burst of flavor in every bite. Another popular item is the Meatball pizza, featuring homemade meatballs, marinara, and gooey mozzarella cheese.
Aside from their delectable pizzas, Jerry's Pizza Mill also serves up hearty sandwiches, refreshing salads, and even classic hamburgers. The menu caters to various tastes and preferences, ensuring there is something for everyone.
Reviewers praise the friendly service and cozy ambiance of this restaurant, making it a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. The BYOB policy and nearby liquor store add an extra layer of convenience for those looking to enjoy a cold beer with their meal.
While the restaurant may be in need of some refurbishments, loyal customers continue to flock to Jerry's Pizza Mill for its delicious food and welcoming atmosphere. If you find yourself in the Waialua area, be sure to stop by and sample some of their delectable offerings.
- Takes Reservations
- Offers Delivery
- Offers Takeout
- Accepts Credit Cards
- Accepts Android Pay
- Accepts Apple Pay
- Outdoor Seating
- Casual Atmosphere
- Good for Groups and Kids
- Good for Lunch and Dinner
- Street and Private Lot Parking Available
- Free Wi-Fi
- TV for Entertainment
- Alcohol Served
- Drive-Thru for Convenience
- Dogs Allowed
- Bike Parking
Best pizza on island by far just incredible ordered a slice and got two for $10 and had to wait about 15 mins but it's so worth it just fantastic
Had an errand on that side of island. Decided to try restaurant since picky grandson loves cheese pizza. So glad we did because the service and food was excellent! Would highly recommend this place!!
The lady here was so sweet, she definitely made our day. They have $5 slice deals on Tuesdays and Thursdays, which was an amazing surprise when we walked in. The pizza was soooo good. Definitely stop here if you get the chance!
This is one of my favorite pizza places on Oahu. It's pretty far from where I live, so I only come a few times a year, but I always enjoy a visit. The staff identify it as NYC style pizza but I feel like there's a hint of CT style in the crust: not thin and foldable slices but a little crispy. We usually get a pizza and the cheese garlic fries and are never disappointed. They sell sodas and have water but a nice perk is BYOB and a little mini mart in the same plaza which sells beer. I often grab a tall can of beer and enjoy it with the pizza. Since I first discovered Jerry's in 2013 they have downsized and no longer have the larger room with the stage and booth seating . I'm not even sure they have a restroom anymore as those were in the back of the large room. I hope that isn't a sign of financial difficulties as this is a great little local place.
The dough is great. Thats always a good start. But yeah, time and time again this little country gem delivers . Clean with friendly service in a subtly kitsch one of a kind country town ambiance. And cherry on top? It's BYOB with a liquor store right across the way. We ordered the Waialua, because when you're at a pizza joint in Waialua... Can't wait to come back next time we come this way.
Wow, the pizza is good from here. Wow wow wow it's always been good and it will always be good because the person owns it demands. That is great pizza. Let me just state that. It has no competition whatsoever!
Great service! We used to come here a lot, after Covid this is the first time in years! Still amazing! Ordered the white pizza and the fettuccine with marinara and meatballs. Also a side of cheese garlic fries. The only item that the wife and I agreed was not worth it was the fries. They seemed like an afterthought either way cheese. Not worth it. The white pizza is fantastic! No matter what always order a large! It's a few bucks more but you'll want the extra! Perfect! The pasta the wife said was good and she ate most of it. I was too full to try it, but I'll take her word for it. Overall well worth the drive to Waialua!
This little hidden gem is tucked away in Waialua. Where the old Waialua sugar mill was located, it is a nostalgic little restaurant. They bake their own bread for their Sub Sandwiches, make a variety of delicious Pizzas, burgers, and side dishes. Today, 1/6/24, we dined in, and the AC was out, and the restaurant is looking like it's in need of some TLC. We love all their food on the menu, and it tastes great. I hope the owner can find a way to refurbish this little establishment. It's a GREAT spot, and you can even BYOB.